Taxation

Please read the article and take a note of any new vocabulary:

In 1789 Benjamin Franklin, one of the Founding Fathers of the USA, wrote in a letter to a colleague that, “In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.” In these modern times of world economic crisis tax has once again become a hotly debated topic for government, business and workers all over the world. There are many different taxes and many different theories of taxation and how to implement them. Governments need revenue to pay for things like Defense and Health Care and tax is the principal source of this revenue. Let’s have a look at some of them.

Taxes

There are several taxes which directly affect us and the most important of these is the tax on what we earn sometimes known as Income Tax. Usually there is an amount of our salary that we can earn which is not subject to taxation this is sometimes called the Personal Allowance. Everything that we earn over that amount is taxed at a certain tax rate. The government sets the level of Personal Allowance and the tax rate as part of its Fiscal Policy and either the companies that we work for deduct the tax and give it to the government or we arrange to pay the tax ourselves.

Another of the most important taxes is Social Security. In most countries this is paid by workers to the state to pay for state medical services and unemployment benefits if we should lose our jobs. Council Tax is paid to local government to help pay for street lighting, rubbish collection and other local services. One of the most controversial taxes is the tax on the things that we buy called Value Added Tax (VAT) in the UK. This tax is added to things ranging from clothes to TVs and even some food items. Even though it is unpopular with the people it remains popular with governments.

Businesses pay taxes too. Corporation Tax and Capital Gains Tax are probably the biggest that they pay. Many big corporations try to negotiate with governments to pay less tax with the threat of withdrawing from the country and moving to another the principal form of leverage that they use.

Tax Systems

The most common system of taxation in the western world isProgressive Taxation. This system taxes people more or less depending on their relative wealth. Therefore poorer people pay less than rich people and companies with smaller profits pay less than companies with big profits. Socialist, or left-wing, governments tend to set their progressive tax rates at the more extreme ends of the scale so that poorer people pay very little in tax and the very rich pay a lot. Conservative, or right-wing, governments tend to set their tax rates lower so that the poorer workers still contribute something and the richer workers pay more but not very much more. Conservatives argue that setting tax rates very high for the rich only encourages tax avoidance and inhibits the production of wealth thereby reducing the amount of tax collected by the government.

Conservatives cite the economist Arthur Laffer who drew a diagram showing how high taxation reduces economic activity and increases tax avoidance. This diagram is called the “Laffer Curve” and this system of taxation has been adopted by conservative governments all over the world. Left-wing economists argue that it is morally right to subject the rich to high taxes especially now in these times of crisis and austerity. There is a fierce debate in the European Union over which system should be employed in its member countries. Some countries have accused Greece and Italy of setting Personal Allowances too high and having systems that encourage tax avoidance. Meanwhile northern countries, like Germany and the UK, are accused of letting high earners pay too little tax. Whatever the rights and wrongs of taxation, the debate is sure to continue.

Discussion

1. Do you agree with the socialist economists who say that the rich have a moral obligation to pay a high rate of tax?
2. What are the Income Tax and Personal Allowance rates in your country?
3. Are you happy with your country’s Fiscal Policy?
4. Is tax avoidance common in your country?
5. Do you think that your government spends its tax revenue wisely?

A Spaniard in London

A Spanish graduate who won three degrees has found the only job available to him is cleaning the bathrooms in a London cafe. Benjamin Serra Bosch, 25, received distinctions for his academic work in journalism and PR but has not be able to find qualified work in Spain or his new home country.

In a frustrated online rant, he outlines the hopeless situation for thousands of young Spaniards like himself who are forced to go abroad to take on jobs for which they are overqualified.

He has two Bachelor degrees, one in Journalism and Advertising and another in Public Relations from the prestigious private CEU Cardenal Herrera University.  He also has a Master's degree in Community Management from the IEBS Business School.  Yet he was not able to find employment in Spain, and after a six-month internship in London, he took a job at a ‘well-known coffee chain’ as a waiter.

‘I received a distinction for both my degrees and now I clean shit in a foreign country,’ he writes.

‘I've been working in a well known café chain in London since May. And after five months working there, today for the first time I saw it clearly.

‘I clean toilets. My thought was “I received distinctions in my two degrees and I clean other peoples shit in a country that isn't my own.” Well, I also make coffees, wipe tables and wash up cups.’

 

The reaction from other young Spaniards, did not take long. Since Friday, his post has been shared over 1,500 times on Facebook alone, with thousands of comments from others in his situation.

Thousands have complained of the hopeless situation for many young people in Spain, where unemployment for under-25s reached 56 per cent in August.

The Valencia native insists in his post that he is not ashamed of working a job he is overqualified for, but rather that, like many others of his generation, he was forced to go abroad to get it as a result of the high unemployment in Spain.

‘I'm not ashamed of what I do. Cleaning is a very worthy job, What embarrasses me is having to do it because no one has given me an opportunity in Spain. There are many Spaniards like me especially in London.

‘I thought I deserved better after so much effort in my academic life. Apparently I was wrong.’

'I know this has transpired because many of us [young Spaniards] find ourselves in the same situation or are parents who have struggled to prepare their children and identify with my situation. Or simply because there are people who see that Spain has spent years living in an untenable position. 

'I am an ordinary person, not a public figure. I never wanted to be the hero of the stories, I just want to tell them.'

All words from The Daily Mail online in the UK

Discussion:

Please give a short summary of the article.

What is your reaction to this article?

Do you know any young people in a similar situation?

Could you live and work abroad?

Would you be willing to clean toilets for a living?

Do you think the situation is improving?

Who do you blame for this situation?